Project

General

Profile

Actions

Feature #8021

closed

Requesting from Radioreference.com.com for a location outside of USA, ie the dreaded invalid county Id

Added by Jean Pichette almost 4 years ago. Updated over 3 years ago.

Status:
Closed
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Category:
-
Target version:
Start date:
06/27/2020
Due date:
% Done:

100%

Estimated time:
Chirp Version:
daily
Model affected:
RadioReference
I read the instructions above:

Description

Greets.

So, been fighting with this, and it’s obvious that the problem is that Chirp sends requests to radioreference.com using a Zipcode API which fails miserably for any non Us locale.
Can’t a dropdown to use “Metro Area” instead of Zipcode (with correct request natch) be added ?
It seems to be used for most Large countries.

Website searches using “County” as a droplist work, so that should be feasible. (No Zipcode search in Canada, but USA does get them, obviously)


Related issues

Related to Bug #8133: RadioReference - "Server raised fault:invalid county id"Closed07/25/2020

Actions
Is duplicate of Bug #4941: Can not get in to Radio ReferenceClosed06/23/2017

Actions
Has duplicate Bug #8061: RadioReference and CanadaClosed07/12/2020

Actions
Is duplicate of Bug #2625: CountryIn Progress06/02/2015

Actions
Has duplicate Bug #5307: Error : "Unknown County Code"Closed11/02/2017

Actions
Has duplicate Bug #8219: invalid county Closed08/29/2020

Actions
Actions #1

Updated by Bernhard Hailer almost 4 years ago

  • Description updated (diff)
  • Status changed from New to Feedback
  • Target version set to chirp-legacy
  • Model affected changed from (All models) to RadioReference

#4941 suggests that this has been resolved recently.
Did you try a recent build?

Actions #2

Updated by Jean Pichette almost 4 years ago

Greets.

June 22nd 2020.
I did test with Actual american zipcodes, and it works for me. Completely useless, but it works. (90210, and a reserve one that I took from the report number in case the actual county ID was used to label the pdr reports generated.)

And tested queries at radioreference. (And double checked a dozen countries while editing this)

The entirety of this problem is that radioreference allows searches by Zipcodes , County and a few other options Like Metropolitan areas etc. .
The options change by country.

Contrary to many databases they don’t seem to equate all the types of postal identifiers, so only real Zipcodes can be found by a zipcode search.
(Note The . Radioreference Website does not allow searching by postal code in canada, so may not actually have the information.)

Chirp ONLY offers to search by Zipcode.

Adding a County search would fix Canada
Adding a Region search would fix many countries, but not canada :) (This seems to be the default for the small countries with a single grouping)

So I’d suggest adding a pull down between Zipcode search, county, and Region. I think that would fix most countries.

P.s. I’m willing to do the entire research and check every listing To see if those 3 options would cover every countries. Might need a fourth, but I’d be surprised.

Jp

Actions #3

Updated by Jean Pichette almost 4 years ago

Tested the July 11th release.

No improvement.

Just keeping this active :)

Actions #4

Updated by Jean Pichette over 3 years ago

Tested the july 22nd

Also, 4941 was a different (tho similar sounding issue) where a specific Zip code in Washington was buggy..

My issue is that there are no Zip Codes outside of the Us, and as long as Chirp will not provide a query by something other than a Zip Code, we can’t use it.
(Well, not the local frequency imports)

Actions #5

Updated by Mark Leigh over 3 years ago

Yes, absurd that no one has tackled this... so I'm on it. Thank goodness it's open source.

Actions #6

Updated by Mark Leigh over 3 years ago

A B wrote:

Yes, absurd that no one has tackled this... so I'm on it. Thank goodness it's open source.

Coming along. Probably a few days away from a pull request.

Actions #7

Updated by Mark Leigh over 3 years ago

This is completed - for Canada!

The radio menu now has a submenu for RadioReference.com under which you can select Canada or USA. Inside the "Canada" option, you select Province and "county" (which is actually a mishmash of "Census geographic units" and Municipalities).

Currently excludes provincewide systems - but some ambitious human could probably take care of that.

I haven't pulled out a radio to test with, but import works well.

Enjoy! Pull request has been sent!

Actions #8

Updated by Mark Leigh over 3 years ago

Mark Leigh wrote:

This is completed - for Canada!

On my version, radio menu now has a submenu for RadioReference.com under which you can select Canada or USA. Inside the "Canada" option, you select Province and "county" (which is actually a mishmash of "Census geographic units" and Municipalities).

Currently excludes provincewide systems - but some ambitious human could probably take care of that.

I haven't pulled out a radio to test with, but import works well.

Enjoy! Pull request has been sent!

Actions #9

Updated by Mark Leigh over 3 years ago

  • Status changed from Feedback to Closed
  • % Done changed from 0 to 100

Applied in changeset commit:e201a439edcc.

Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF